Gel vs. Acrylic: Which is Better for Weak Nails?

Flexibility makes Gel nails better for weak nails, whereas acrylic nails can be too rigid and harsh and may cause more damage.”

If you’ve got weak nails, you know how tough it is to keep them looking great without doing more damage. You had dreamt of those long, beautiful nails but always ended up having a breakage? That’s common, but don’t worry. 

Gel and acrylic nails could be your new BFFs. So, with both options out there, which one’s better for your weak nails? The gel vs. acrylic debate is real. Let me break down the pros and cons of each to help you choose.

Gel Nails

Gel nails are a type of manicure that uses gel-based polish. They’re applied like regular nail polish but get cured under a UV or LED light to harden.

If you want a natural, glossy look, gel nails are the way to go. They look more natural compared to the thicker look of acrylics. Plus, gel nails are more flexible and less likely to chip. Sarah Gibson Tuttle; the CEO and founder of Olive and June confirms this on Byrdie; “Gel manicures are more resistant to chips and wear and tear.” 

Pros of Gel Manicures for Weak Nails

1. Less Removal Damage: Soak-off gels are way kinder to your nails compared to acrylics. Acrylics need heavy-duty filing and a long acetone soak, which, at times, can be a nightmare for your weak nails. 
2. Strengthens Natural Nails: Hard gels work like a shield, giving your natural nails a boost in strength. 
3. Rarely breaks: Gel nails are more flexible. They actually bend with your natural nails so are less likely to crack or break even with weak nails. 
4. Lighter weight: Gel nails feel lighter and more natural, putting less stress on your weak nails.

Cons of Gel Manicures for Weak Nails 

1. Harsh Removal: Soaking in acetone to remove gels can be super tough and dry on weak nails. 
2. Less Durable: Gel nails don’t last as long as acrylics do. 
3. Drying Effect: Gel polish can dry out your nails, making them more brittle under the polish.

When it comes to weak nails, kindness is the key. Avoid any aggressive filing or buffing; instead, do it lightly to help the gel stick. Apply the gel in thin, even layers because thick layers are heavy and put extra stress on weak nails (and we definitely don’t want that). Be sure to seal the edges by capping the free edge of your nail with gel, as this prevents lifting and chipping.

Never ever pick or peel off your gel nails. Properly follow at-home removal techniques, or better, get them taken off professionally.

Acrylic Nails

Acrylic nails are fake nails created by mixing a liquid and a powder to form a strong, protective layer over your natural nails. 

Pros of Acrylics Manicures for Weak Nails

1. Durability: Acrylics are 3 times more durable than gel nails, making them less likely to chip or break. Totally clutch if you need something long-lasting!

2. Customizable: You can adjust the thickness and strength of the acrylics. This means you can get the support you need, tailored just for your weak nails.

Cons of Acrylic Nails for Weak Nails

1. Rigidity: Acrylics are super rigid, so if they break, they cause damage.

2. Chemical Exposure: Weak nails are often sensitive to strong chemicals and fumes, involved in the process of acrylic application.
3. Heaviness: Acrylics can feel heavier on your nails compared to gels, adding extra stress to already stressed nails.
4. Acetone: The removal process is the same as gels. It involves soaking in acetone, which can further weaken and dry out your nails.
5. Infections: There’s a risk of infections if the acrylic nails lift or are left uncleaned. “Infection can develop in the gap that forms between the two nails, especially if the artificial nail is reglued before a thorough cleaning”. Source my health

Always go to a skilled nail technician to get your acrylics done. They’ll know how to apply them without damaging your natural nails. It’s also a good idea to opt for shorter lengths—they’re just as cute and put less stress on your nails. Check out our gallery of 75 Classy short nails for inspo.

When it comes to removal, always have your acrylics taken off by a professional. Avoid peeling or prying them off yourself, as this can really mess up your nails. And don’t forget to give your nails a break between acrylic sets so your natural nails have time to breathe and recover.

Summing it up:

Feature	Gel Nails	Acrylic Nails
Flexibility	More flexible, reduces breakage risk	More rigid, higher risk of damage
Appearance	Natural and glossy finish	Thicker, less natural look
Durability	Less durable, may chip more easily	Very durable, longer-lasting
Application	Cured under UV/LED light, gentler	Strong chemicals, harsher application

If your nails are weak, I’d totally recommend going with gel nails. But honestly, it’s all about what you need. If you’re after durability, acrylics can work too. Figure out why your nails are struggling. If that’s diet, eat foods rich in vitamins and minerals, especially biotin.