Gel vs Shellac vs Dip Powder: Which Manicure Is Right for You?

Picking the perfect manicure can feel like a big decision. Each option has its own vibe, durability, and maintenance level. Gel, Shellac, and dip powder are three of the most popular choices out there, but they’re not quite the same. In this post, we’ll break down the differences, pros and cons, and help you figure out which one’s gonna work best for your lifestyle. Let’s dive in!

What Are These Manicures, Anyway?

All three options are longer-lasting than regular polish, but they work in totally different ways. Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let’s define what we’re talking about here.

Gel Manicure

A gel manicure uses a special polish that’s cured (aka hardened) under a UV or LED lamp. It’s known for its glossy finish and chip-resistant nature. Think of it as a souped-up version of regular nail polish with extra staying power.

Get to know the difference between a Gel fill and a gel manicure

Shellac Manicure

Shellac is actually a brand name (by CND) for a hybrid polish that combines gel and traditional nail polish. It also gets cured under a UV lamp, but it’s a bit thinner and more flexible than regular gel. People often use “Shellac” to mean any gel manicure, but it’s its own thing.

Dip Powder Manicure

Dip powder involves dipping your nails into a colored powder (or brushing it on) after applying a base coat, then sealing it with a topcoat. No UV lamp needed here—it air-dries. It’s a thicker, more durable option that’s gained a ton of fans lately.

Gel vs Shellac vs dip powder application

The application process can make or break your experience. Some methods are quick, others take a bit more time.

Gel Manicure Application

1. Prep: Nails are cleaned, shaped, and lightly buffed.
2. Base Coat: A thin base layer is applied and cured under a UV/LED lamp.
3. Color: Two to three layers of gel polish go on, each cured under the lamp.
4. Top Coat: A glossy topcoat seals it all in, also cured.
5. Time: About 45 minutes to an hour.

Shellac Manicure Application

1. Prep: Same as gel—clean, shape, buff.
2. Base Coat: Shellac base coat goes on, cured under a UV lamp.
3. Color: Two layers of Shellac polish, each cured.
4. Top Coat: Shellac topcoat, cured again.
5. Time: Around 30-45 minutes (a bit faster than gel since it’s thinner).

Dip Powder Application

1. Prep: Nails cleaned, shaped, and buffed.
2. Base Coat: A bonding agent is brushed on.
3. Dipping: Nails are dipped into powder (or powder is brushed on), repeated 2-3 times.
4. Activator: A liquid seals the powder, making it hard.
5. Top Coat: A glossy topcoat (sometimes buffed for shine).
6. Time: About 45 minutes to an hour.

Durability and Longevity Difference

How long your mani lasts can be a dealbreaker. Let’s see how they stack up.

Gel nails lasts about 2-3 weeks before you start seeing chips or growth at the base. It’s tough but can lift if you’re hard on your hands.

Shellac manicure typically lasts around 2 weeks. It’s a bit more flexible than gel, so it might not hold up as well if you’re doing a lot of heavy lifting.

Dip Powder nails can last 3-4 weeks, sometimes even longer. It’s super durable and less likely to chip, but regrowth can look more obvious since it’s thicker.

Removal Process

Taking off your manicure is just as important as putting it on. Here’s how each one comes off.

Gel Removal

Soak cotton pads in acetone, place them on your nails, and wrap with foil. Allow the acetone to work for 10-15 minutes, softening the gel. After this time, gently scrape away the loosened gel(Can be tough on your nails if not done carefully!).

Shellac Removal

Shellac removal follows a similar process. Soak cotton pads in acetone and wrap your fingertips in foil for approximately 10 minutes. Shellac typically breaks down more readily than gel, resulting in easier removal and less need for scraping. However, it is still essential to handle your nails with care to prevent any harm.

Dip Powder Removal

For dip powder removal, soak your nails in acetone for a longer period, typically 15-20 minutes. This can be done by submerging your fingertips in a bowl of acetone or by using foil wraps.

The dip powder will dissolve into a goopy consistency, which can then be wiped away. This process may require more time than gel or Shellac removal, and some light buffing might be necessary to remove any remaining residue.

Cost Comparison

Prices can vary depending on your salon, location, and any extras (like nail art). Here’s a general idea:

Manicure Type	Average Cost (USD)	Notes
Gel	$35–$60	Pricey if you add designs or extensions.
Shellac	$30–$50	Usually a bit cheaper than full gel.
Dip Powder	$40–$65	Higher upfront, but lasts longer.

Pros and Cons of Each

Every manicure has its highs and lows. Here’s the rundown.

Gel Manicure

• Pros:
  • Shiny, glossy finish.
  • Wide range of colors.
  • Lasts longer than regular polish.
  • Dries instantly under light (no smudges!).
• Cons:
  • UV lamp exposure (small risk of skin damage over time).
  • Removal can weaken nails if not done right.
  • Might chip if you’re rough on your hands.

Shellac Manicure

• Pros:
  • Less filing/prep than gel = gentler on nails.
  • Soaks off faster (10–15 minutes vs. 20+ for gel).
  • Natural, lightweight feel.
• Cons:
  • Slightly less durable than gel or dip.
  • Limited color range compared to gel or dip.
  • Also requires UV lamp.

Dip Powder Manicure

• Pros:
  • Super durable, great for active lifestyles.
  • No UV lamp needed.
  • Can add strength to weak nails.
• Cons:
  • Thicker look, not as “natural” as gel or Shellac.
  • Removal takes longer and can be messy.
  • Harder to do at home without practice.

---

Which Is Better for Your Nails?

Nail health is a big concern—nobody wants brittle, peeling nails. Here’s how each option affects your natural nails.

• Gel: Can be drying over time due to acetone removal. Regular breaks between manicures help.
• Shellac: Slightly gentler than gel since it’s thinner and easier to remove, but still needs acetone.
• Dip Powder: Adds a protective layer, which can help if your nails are weak. But improper removal (like peeling it off) can cause damage.

Tip: No matter what you choose, give your nails some TLC—moisturize with cuticle oil and take breaks every few months to let them breathe.

---

Style and Aesthetic

Looking for a specific vibe? Here’s how they compare.

• Gel: Super glossy and sleek. Great for a polished, professional look or bold nail art.
• Shellac: Similar to gel but a bit more understated. Perfect if you want something classy but not over-the-top.
• Dip Powder: Thicker, so it looks more “structured.” Awesome for matte finishes or trendy textured designs.

---

Which Should You Choose?

It really comes down to your lifestyle, budget, and what you’re looking for in a mani. Here’s a quick guide to help you decide:

Pick Gel If…

• You want glossy, Instagram-worthy nails.
• You change your color every 2–3 weeks.
• You’re okay with UV light (or use SPF gloves).

Pick Shellac If…

• You have thin or weak nails.
• You’re after something low-maintenance with a decent wear time
• You want an easier removal process.
• You prefer a natural look.

Pick Dip Powder If…

• You hate waiting for polish to dry.
• You don’t mind a thicker look.
• You need something that’ll last through anything (work, gym, dishes)
• You want a manicure that survives vacations.

---

Conclusion

There’s no “best” option—just what’s best for you.

• Budget-friendly + quick: Shellac.
• Durability queen: Dip Powder.
• Glossy and versatile: Gel.

Whichever you choose, rock those nails guilt-free! 💅

Got questions? Slide into our DMs—we’re here to chat all things manicures.